I have so many points to cram into this entry, I'm not sure if I will succeed in doing that, let alone find a way to knit them together and form a cohesive argument. Maybe if I just dump out the mess in my head, it'll be the first step. Maybe this is just where I build a thesis and clarity comes later, with this entry serving as a way to show my work. Whichever way, its all been on my mind. And so I begin.
Last week, Malik "Phife Dawg" Taylor died at 45. This was a punch in the gut for me, as his defunct hip hop group, A Tribe Called Quest, was hugely influential in my life, and they remain in my top 5 bands of all time. He was too young and it's a celebrity death that really touched me, touched way more people than I would have guessed. So RIP Phife, I will always and forever love you and the music you brought to the world. This isn't about him at all, though, it just stems from the aftermath of his death when I listened to ATCQ on the heaviest rotation since 1994. On the band's seminal Low End Theory album, Phife delivers a virtuoso performance on the song "Butter," a two-verse classic boast/diss track. It's a genius number with a singular delivery (by the by,"you get an E for effort, and T for nice try" is incredibly useful for the parent of a five-year-old). On it, Phife boasts about his prowess as a rapper and ladies' man, but then instead of dissing other MCs, he disses female fans who wouldn't give him the time of day before he was famous. And that's cool, I mean nobody likes a fame grabber. But the dissing takes a weird turn partway through the second verse:
Now tell me what's the reason, for dyin' your hair
Slum village gold still danglin in your ear
You barely have a neck but still sportin' a rope
Four-finger ring just so Phifer can scope
You looked in the mirror, didn't know what to do
Yesterday your eyes were brown but today they are blue
Your whole appearance is a lie and it could never be true
And if you really loved yourself then you would try and be you
If your hair and eyes were real, I wouldn't have dissed ya
But since it was bought, I had to dismiss ya
If you can't achieve it, then why not try and weave it
If you can't extend it then you might as well suspend it
If you can't braid it, best thing to do is fade it
I asked who did your hair and you tell me "Diane made it"
If you were you and just you, talk to you, maybe
But I can't stand, no bionic lady
Tryin' hard to look fly, but yo, you're lookin' dumber
If I wanted someone like you I woulda swung with Jamie Summers
To recap: ladies, here's a beauty standard for you to achieve. If you don't look this way naturally, fake it. BUT if I can tell you're faking it, that's worse. You're ugly AND a failure at making yourself a swan and you tried to pull a fast one on my ego so you are double punished. How dare you? And how dare you change your appearance and be capable of loving yourself?
Womenfolk: HOW CAN YOU WIN?
This is just an example, I don't mean to single out Phife, especially when he and his crew are historically at the least misogynistic end of the rap lyric spectrum. I also acknowledge that he's addressing the problematic rejection of racial and cultural identity in appearance, which I am in no way qualified to discuss. But overall it's an insidious, pervasive little message - he admires a groupie's hair until he finds out it's a weave, and reacts by shaming her for the anger and disappointment she caused. Basically, "girl, you were almost good enough, until you weren't, and I feel like a fool so you should feel worse." It rings in my ear because I've been thinking a lot about the movement that posits that taking and sharing selfies is a feminist act. I don't know about that, or that I could ever say that an act is inherently feminist or not, only using the logic that an act done by someone who identifies as a feminist makes it feminist. Ergo, when I take a selfie, I am a feminist taking a selfie and it's technically a feminist act. My actions only apply to me and don't represent all of feminism as a movement, if it is even only one thing.
Er, before I lose us all to semantics quicksand (if you are even interested in being pulled out at this point), here are my thoughts on selfies. Self-portraits are as old as time, it's just that the technology exists now that allows people to take and share them indiscriminately. That's not a bad or good thing in itself, it's just establishing the landscape. And when the act of living in a body subjects you to everyone's judgment every second of the day, if you want to put your image out there, you should feel confident in your power to control it, without justification or apology. If that means ten layers of filters, or a statement that you are not wearing makeup, or a full frontal nudie, who is anyone else so say? Everybody's got their thing. I don't actually care, if you are an adult and you own it, if you feel empowered by it, harness that power. It doesn't mean I will refrain from reacting to what I see with a, "Oh honey, no." But I'm trying to curb that reaction. Because at the heart of it, it's the same. Even if I know what I'm seeing is fake. Even if I know it's a ploy for attention and validation. So what? What's really real anyway? Is it a crime to seek attention, good or bad, when you're given the message that it's only other people's opinion of your physical self that matters anyway?
I'm not saying that's why I do it, or why anyone does it, if it's something they like to do. I know my own ever-shifting motivations, and I can think I know others', but I don't, not really. On one hand, it doesn't matter why. On the other hand, it does matter, but the different "whys" are so complex I'd be following the trails to each problematic thought process until the cows came home, because society is society and the female body is the subject of scrutiny at all times, and girls internalize messages about their bodies from a very very young age, including the idea of ownership.
And there's the overarching message OF COURSE, that appearance is the most important thing. It shouldn't be and I don't want it to be and I don't want to play into it. And I do, I mean, for example, I like to watch Intervention. Enough people do to make it a successful reality series so I'm not alone in my pain voyeurism, but I am not actually sure what it does for me besides make me sad/extra grateful I've never had to deal with addiction. The other night I realized, as I was wondering if there is truly a correlation between female addicts and terrible eyebrows, that 1) I have too many opinions about strangers' eyebrows and 2) THIS is what I'm taking away from the show about seriously sick people? What kind of monster does that make me? I don't want to be that kind of monster.
I don't have any answers. I don't have a conclusion. It's all just... there. Hanging out there. Maybe, if nothing else, this starts a discussion with people whose opinions I really respect, or makes someone aware of the pressure to be a person whose experience is very different form theirs where they hadn't been before. I don't know. All I know is, I'm tired now. And I have no plans to stop taking selfies any time soon. A small reason is that if I don't photograph myself, who will? I am interested in seeing myself during different points in my history as I am in everyone else. But I also have the luxury of decent self-esteem, which I didn't always have, and I think that if this is when I was coming of age, I'd have a very different relationship with putting my image out there.