I'm a lifelong fan of rap and hip-hop music. Full stop. I love the diversity within the genre. I love hardcore gangsta and dancy hip-pop. Serious message-oriented stuff, songs that preach positivity, nihlistic narratives and songs about having it rough. I love the lot of it. And while I am happy to listen and dance and whatever (hip-hop is my go-to choice for the treadmill, for sure), I don't feel comfortable singing along to certain songs, even when I'm alone, because of one word more than any other. And that's good, I think. I don't need to feel comfortable with saying this word. It shouldn't be a comfortable thing. I don't even like to hear it, frankly, from anyone, but if I ever want to listen to anything from the past 20 years, I have to get over that. I understand about taking ownership of something, about gaining power by claiming something that has been used against you. I'm not even saying "HEY A$AP AND CO., CLEAN UP YOUR LANGUAGE SO AS NOT TO OFFEND MY DELICATE EARS." I accept the music for what it is, and I can separate what I hear from what I apply to my own life. As I've gone around and around the mulberry bush with how my feminism and music fandom can co-exist, I'm just thinking about it a lot lately, now that my kid parrots everything, how I can reconcile being a hip-hop fan and a responsible parent. And for now, I think I can leave the non-radio versions of, uh, language-y songs to solo drives and headphones. It's not like it's a burden for poor me to give up my beloved jams. Music that other people write is not about me. I can choose to listen to it or not and that's cool. And I'm not trying to unrealistically shelter HR, he's going to hear all the world's words eventually and better he be armed with the proper outlook. These things we don't say and why. Which words are offensive because they are naughty and vulgar and which just plain hurt people. The teaching moments will present themselves, I know. But I don't think it's too early to start thinking about the conversation. My god, yesterday he said he hated the Comcast guys who came to our house, and I don't remember ever, ever using that word in front of him (whether he has a point is another story).
On one hand, words are just that. Things you say. They can be meant or not. They can paint a picture, tell a story, transport you to a world beyond. They can be true, they can be art, they can be either or neither or both. And they have so much power. I want my child to grow up with respect for that. In the Voldemort school, they only have as much power as you give them. And that's true to an extent, though to me that's mostly when they're being used against you. What's more important to me when navigating the idea of "good" and "bad" words with HR is that he knows how he could use them as weapons. At this age I tread very carefully, and that includes clomping all over my ideals. For example I just can't bring myself to read the line "Shut up!" in Frog and Toad Together, I always soften it to "Be quiet!" because I don't want HR to think that "shut up" is an acceptable thing to say, and I don't want to take away from the story by explaining that every time. In a vacuum, I vehemently oppose censorship. I would much rather have a conversation about what's offensive than ban it outright, but it also doesn't mean I have to make flashcards for the nursery. It's all part of the make-it-up-as-I-go process of totally messing up--I mean raising--my kid.
My parents always swore in our presence, and we kids knew these were grown up words. Slurs were never a part of the picture, and if we dared to say something for shock value, it would never have been tolerated. I've said this a million times, my mother was the first civil rights activist I knew, and I knew her as such simply by the example she set. I feel like we internalized the message about words, but I'm sure it wasn't so effortless, so inborn. There was a reason we knew, and I'm sure it's because we talked about it. And if I don't remember the talk but I do remember the lesson that came of it, I guess that's more important.
There are a whole lot of unfinished thoughts in here, so please bear with. Even though the thought process was brought about by one racially charged word, this isn't about race or sexual orientation or love or hate or prejudice. Those are going to be awesome fun-time topics to address down the line. But for now, this is just me thinking about words. I think about words a lot. And if I sound like I'm afraid of words, well I am, because I know what they can do. And I love words more than people, almost. So I try to treat them with respect. Though this partially nonsensical jumble may imply the opposite.